The Emotional Equity Model

Sport organisations regularly ask something of fans through social media: watch this, buy a ticket, support our sponsor, stick with us after another loss. How those requests are received is shaped, in part, by what the organisation has given fans along the way.

The Emotional Equity Model treats that relationship as an emotional bank account. The balance reflects the trust, goodwill and connection built over time, with every post capable of adding to it or drawing it down.

I developed the model through conversations with sport social media practitioners across New Zealand and Australia in November 2025, exploring how everyday content decisions contribute to that balance and what a strong relationship with fans makes possible.

How the model developed

I initially expected different types of posts to have relatively predictable effects, with humour making a deposit, for example, and sponsored content making a withdrawal. Practitioners’ experiences challenged that assumption: a commercial post could offer fans something they valued, while a joke could create frustration if the timing or tone felt wrong.

Within the model, every post therefore starts neutral, regardless of its type. Some content may be more likely to prompt a positive or negative response, but its category alone doesn’t determine whether it makes a deposit or a withdrawal, or by how much.

Instead, the model brings together four conditions:

  • Context: What is happening when the post lands, including results, timing, fan mood and wider events.

  • Execution: How the post is presented through its format, tone, storytelling and visual choices.

  • Capacity: What the team has the access, time, resources and approvals to deliver.

  • Existing balance: The trust, goodwill and connection already built with fans, including their expectations of the account.

These conditions help explain why similar content can land differently across accounts, audiences and moments.

Why a strong balance matters

The value of a healthy balance becomes clearer when an organisation wants to try something different, deliver for a commercial partner or maintain connection through a difficult season. Fans who have consistently found value in an account may be more willing to give a new approach a chance, engage with sponsored content or keep following when results give them little to celebrate.

That history may also provide some goodwill when a post misses, allowing fans to understand it within a longer relationship. It doesn’t make an account immune to criticism, and the balance is always changing as new posts and interactions shape how fans feel.

Using the model in practice

The model offers a starting point for discussing a planned post, reflecting on an unexpected response or working through competing priorities with colleagues. Before publishing, a team might ask:

  • How might fans feel about this post given what is happening right now?

  • What does it offer fans, and what are we asking of them?

  • Do we have the time, access and resources to deliver it well?

  • Does the format and tone fit the message?

  • How might fans respond given their existing relationship with us?

These questions also create space to discuss the organisational conditions behind content decisions. Access, approvals, staffing and commercial commitments all influence what practitioners can deliver, so responsibility for building the balance extends beyond the person pressing publish.

The central question is:

What could this post add to or take from the balance you’re building with fans?

Download the model

The one-page overview brings the model together as a reference for content planning, teaching and team discussions.

Download the one-page overview

Workshops and team sessions

If you’d like to use the model with your team, I’m happy to talk it through or run a session using your own content and examples.

Get in touch

Thank you to the practitioners across New Zealand and Australia who generously shared their time, experiences and honest insights to help shape this work.